n8n vs Make vs Zapier: compare tasks, credits, and workflow control
n8n vs Make vs Zapier: compare tasks, credits, and workflow control
Choose an automation platform by the process you need to operate and the person who will maintain it. Start with Zapier when your required app actions fit its connectors and a department owns the workflow. Consider Make when visual data mapping and branching dominate the job. Consider n8n when code, internal systems, or self-hosting requirements are central.
These are selection criteria, not benchmark results. This comparison uses official documentation checked on October 23, 2026. No customer interviews or savings measurements support a universal winner.
Check the exact action before comparing catalogs
An integration count does not tell you whether a connector supports custom fields, attachments, pagination, or the account role you use. Write down the required trigger and every read or write action. Test them with representative records before selecting a platform.
For a lead-routing workflow, verify how the connector finds an existing account, updates the correct owner, and handles an ambiguous match. For order processing, verify how line items branch and aggregate. For an internal database, verify the actual network path and credentials. Self-hosted n8n can be placed inside your environment, but the team must operate that deployment.
Visual workflow automation for APIs, business systems, and AI steps, with cloud and self-hosted editions.
Visual cloud automation with scenarios, data mapping, routing, and credit-based usage.
Cloud automation that connects application triggers and actions, with task-based usage and plan-specific controls.
The billing units are different
| Platform | Main usage unit | What the estimate must include |
|---|---|---|
| n8n paid plans | Production workflow executions | Event frequency, concurrency, duration, and external services |
| Make | Credits | Module runs, bundles, and fixed or dynamic AI rates |
| Zapier | Tasks | Successful actions, exemptions, and product-specific rates |
n8n currently excludes manual runs, sub-workflow executions, and error workflows from the execution quota. A workflow having more steps does not by itself increase its execution count. Runtime, concurrency, and external API costs still matter. See execution accounting and pricing.
Make credits replaced operations as the billing unit. Most non-AI operations consume one credit, but AI and advanced features can consume credits at different fixed or dynamic rates. Iterators and search results can multiply downstream work. Its Free plan currently includes 1,000 credits monthly. Read Make's credit rules and pricing.
Zapier normally counts successful actions as tasks. Triggers, Filters, Paths, and several built-in tools have exemptions. AI tiers, extended code runtime, and MCP calls can follow different rates. Agents uses a separate activity allowance. Free currently includes 100 tasks monthly and two-step Zaps. See task accounting and pricing.
These allowances are not interchangeable. Estimate the same business workload in each platform and inspect its actual usage history. Add model-provider fees, connected-app subscriptions, and operating work before comparing totals.
Test the failure after the successful write
A useful pilot creates a record, then simulates a timeout before the workflow receives confirmation. Replay the event and check whether another record appears. A retry button cannot replace an idempotency strategy.
Also test expired credentials, API throttling, empty searches, and an unauthorized action. Record who receives the alert, which data the history exposes, and whether another team member can repair the workflow. Check history retention, shared connections, access controls, and overage behavior on the exact plan.
Choose with an operating owner
Zapier and Make are hosted services under their service agreements. n8n offers cloud and self-hosted editions, but its Sustainable Use License is source-available with use restrictions. Shared projects, SSO, and Git environments are paid-edition decisions. Review the n8n license and edition comparison before procurement.
Choose the candidate that supports your exact actions, meets the failure tests, and has an owner who can maintain it. Approve a budget using the pilot's billing history and a documented volume estimate. Avoid a price ranking based only on the advertised monthly entry price.